What Is the Difference Between Fair Wear and Tear and Damage?
Fair wear and tear is the deterioration that happens to any home over time with ordinary use, while damage is harm caused by a negligent, careless or deliberate act. The same item can fall either side depending on how it happened.
The NSW Government’s page on fair wear and tear versus damage says the tenant is responsible for negligent, irresponsible or intentional actions that damage the property, and for damage caused by other occupants or guests. The tenant is not responsible for fair wear and tear. The page does not give a one-line definition. It uses paired examples instead, and they are the clearest guide there is:
- Floors: scuffed wooden floors are wear. Badly scratched or gouged floors are damage.
- Carpet: furniture dents and traffic marks are wear. Stains and burns are damage.
- Paint: faded, chipped or cracked paint is wear. An unapproved, poor quality paint job is damage.
- Doors and windows: loose hinges or handles and worn sliding tracks are wear. Broken glass is damage.
- Kitchen: a worn benchtop is wear. Burns or cuts in it are damage.
- Water stains: stains from rain through a leaking roof or bad plumbing are wear. Stains from an overflowing bath or indoor pot plants are damage.
- Walls: paint worn off near a light switch is wear. Paint pulled off with Blu-Tack or sticky tape is damage.
Does the age of the property change things?
Yes. The landlord’s duty is to keep the property in reasonable repair, and what is reasonable depends on its age.
NSW’s page on landlord responsibilities for repair and maintenance says a reasonable state of repair takes into account the age of the property, the rent being paid and its prospective life, and that it does not mean the property must be in perfect condition. A 40-year-old weatherboard on the coast will show more wear after a two-year lease than a new townhouse, and a tenant should not be charged for that.
Who Pays for Repairs in a Rental Property in NSW?
The landlord pays to keep the property in reasonable repair, and the tenant pays to repair damage they caused or allowed. Tenants also handle a short list of minor maintenance.
NSW’s page on rental property maintenance responsibilities sets out both sides. Landlords must provide the property reasonably clean and fit to live in, maintain it in reasonable repair, and make any repairs noted in the original condition report. Tenants must keep it reasonably clean, tell the landlord about any damage or disrepair as soon as possible, leave it as close as possible to how they found it, allowing for fair wear and tear, and pay for damage they caused or allowed. That includes damage by anyone the tenant let onto the property.
- Tenant’s minor maintenance: replacing light bulbs, cleaning windows, dusting, removing cobwebs, and routine garden care such as watering, mowing and weeding.
- Landlord’s side: everything that wears out with time, from sticking doors and worn sliding tracks to roof leaks and rotted timber.
- Tenant’s side: anything broken, burnt, stained or gouged through carelessness or on purpose.
Does the landlord have to fix damage the tenant caused?
No, but a landlord who later claims the cost must try to keep it down.
The maintenance responsibilities page says the landlord is not required to fix any damage a tenant causes, but must try to limit the cost of any repair or replacement if they want to claim compensation later. A full door replacement where a new panel or a patch would do is hard to justify. The NSW fair wear and tear page also says a tenant is not financially responsible for damage caused by domestic abuse if they are not the perpetrator, and the bond cannot be used to cover it.
Can a tenant organise repairs themselves?
Only with the landlord’s written consent, except for urgent repairs.
NSW’s guide to getting repairs done says a tenant who wants to organise non-urgent repairs needs the landlord’s consent and agreement to pay, in writing. For urgent repairs, a tenant who cannot reach the landlord or agent can use a licensed tradesperson and be reimbursed up to $1,000, paid back within 14 days. Our guide to rental property minimum standards in NSW covers which repairs count as urgent.
How Do You Tell Wear From Damage on Doors, Floors and Decks?
Look at the cause, not the symptom: wear shows up slowly and evenly where things get used, while damage shows up suddenly in one spot and usually has a clear cause. Most of the time the building tells you which it is.
The official examples cover the inside of the house. A builder gets asked about the rest of it, and the same test applies. These are the calls that come up most often on Central Coast rentals:
- A door that sticks or won’t latch: usually movement in the house or a worn hinge, which is wear. A split frame or a hole in the door is damage.
- Deck boards: greying, checking and lifting nails are weather and age. Burn marks under a barbecue or gouges from dragged furniture are damage.
- Soft floor near a bathroom: usually a long-term leak or failed waterproofing, which is the landlord’s repair. The tenant’s part is whether they reported the signs.
- Flyscreens: brittle mesh after years of sun is wear. A fresh tear at pet height is damage.
- Fences and gates: rotted posts and a sagging gate are age. A section knocked flat by a car is damage.
What if the tenant didn’t report a problem?
Tenants must tell the landlord about damage or disrepair as soon as possible, so an unreported problem that got worse is a fair question to raise.
A small leak left for months can rot a subfloor that a quick repair would have saved. The leak itself is still the landlord’s repair. Whether the tenant should share the extra cost is a matter for the agent, the landlord and, if it comes to it, the Tribunal. A builder’s part is to say plainly how long the damage looks to have been there.
How Do You Prove Fair Wear and Tear at the End of a Lease?
With the condition report from the start of the tenancy, backed by time-stamped photos, compared with the property on the way out.
NSW’s page on rental property condition reports calls the report evidence of how the property was before the tenant moved in, and says it can be used at the end of a tenancy to check what is fair wear and tear and what might be damage. All damage, including minor damage, should be noted on it. The more detail and the more time-stamped photos it has, the less likely a dispute becomes. Tenants should return their completed copy within seven days of moving in.
At the end of the lease, NSW’s page on getting your bond back says a landlord or agent who claims against the bond without giving the tenant evidence is in breach of the Residential Tenancies Act 2010. Disputes that cannot be settled can go to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.
What does good evidence of a repair look like?
A written scope, photos before and after, and an invoice that matches the scope.
A line that says ‘repair door’ invites an argument. One that says the door was split at the latch, the frame was sound, and a new door was hung and painted to match, with photos, rarely does. The same paperwork helps the landlord show they kept the property in reasonable repair.
When Should a Property Manager Call a Builder?
When the repair touches the structure, keeps coming back, or needs a cause written down for a bond claim or an owner. A handyman can patch a symptom. A builder should find out why it happened.
Sticking doors, soft floors, leaking windows, rotted deck posts and fences that lean all have a cause underneath, and fixing the symptom alone usually means paying twice. Residential building work worth more than $5,000 in labour and materials must be done by a licensed contractor, according to NSW’s page on checking your contractor is qualified. That threshold was current in October 2026.
Access needs notice too. NSW’s minimum notice periods for access require at least 2 days’ notice to carry out or assess necessary repairs, and none for urgent repairs. Booking the builder’s look and the tenant’s notice together saves a second visit. For decks in particular, our deck repairs page explains how a frame is checked before anything is priced.
So Who Pays for Rental Repairs?
The landlord pays for what wears out and the tenant pays for what gets broken. When it is not obvious, the condition report, the photos and a builder’s written view of the cause decide it.
Most disputes over wear and tear start with a thin condition report and end with a vague invoice. Detailed records at the start, prompt reporting during the lease and a clear scope for every repair take most of the heat out of the end of a tenancy.
Williamson Builds carries out rental and strata repairs for property managers and landlords across all of the Central Coast, with Newcastle and Sydney by arrangement for larger jobs, under builder’s licence 399743C with $10 million in public liability cover. See our page on home repairs and maintenance for the jobs we take on. This guide is general information for NSW and is not legal advice, so check the NSW Government pages linked above for the current rules.
